There's a type of content that crosses every bubble — religious, skeptical, political, cultural. It appears in family group chats, becomes a trend on Reels, resurfaces in waves on YouTube, and always produces the same result: thousands of comments mixing tears, anger, and debate.
The name is simple: psychographed letters.
For some, they're messages of comfort. For others, they're exploitation of pain. And for many people, they've become something even more dangerous: a sellable product, with "delivery deadlines," "packages," "extra fees," and promises that leave any grieving person vulnerable.
But the story reaches another level when the topic leaves social media and enters the courtroom.
In November 2025, Brazil's Superior Court of Justice (STJ) published a ruling that put a legal "brake" on the matter: psychographed letters cannot be used as judicial evidence.
And if the Justice system says this can't become evidence… why do so many people treat it as "absolute truth" online?
That's what we'll investigate here — without disrespecting faith, without mocking pain, but also without pretending opportunism doesn't exist.
What Are Psychographed Letters and Why They Move People So Much
"Psychography" is the term used, especially in Spiritism and mediumistic practices, to describe texts that would be "dictated" by spirits and written by mediums. For believers, it's a bridge. For non-believers, it's a human production — conscious or unconscious.
But there's one point that doesn't depend on what you believe: a psychographed letter always operates in the most sensitive place of human experience — longing, guilt, the question that's never answered, the "what if…".
And that's why the topic goes viral so easily.
It offers:
- Quick emotional closure
- Ready-made narrative (with beginning, middle, and end)
- Sense of presence
- A type of relief that seems immediate
But the internet transformed this relief into engagement fuel. And engagement, you know: becomes money.
The Trigger: The Psychographed Letter in the Kiss Nightclub Trial
Brazil had seen mediumistic controversies before. But a recent episode was so strong it became a watershed moment.
In the trial of the Kiss Nightclub case (a tragedy that killed 242 people in Santa Maria, RS), the defense of one defendant presented an alleged psychographed letter attributed to one of the victims during the debates. This generated enormous repercussion, public outrage, and a debate that crossed media, law, and social networks.
The shock happened for an obvious reason: when the "voice" is attributed to someone who died, the moral weight seems gigantic. But at the same time, a question arises that can't be avoided:
Who validates this voice?
And more: in a jury environment, with ordinary people deciding, the risk of emotional influence becomes a central theme — and this appears explicitly in the STJ discussion later.
What the STJ Decided and Why This Changes the Game (2025)
On November 5, 2025, the Sixth Panel of the STJ published a ruling determining that psychographed letters cannot be accepted as evidence and must be removed from the case.
The central point was the lack of "minimum reliability" and the fact that psychography is an act of faith, not an element capable of rational validation in the evidence model.
The STJ also highlighted the danger of irrational elements influencing jurors — meaning: it's not just "personal taste," it's a real procedural risk.
Translation to everyday language:
- Evidence needs to be something the other party can contest and investigate
- Psychographed letters don't allow authorship verification in the legal sense
- In jury trials, emotional appeal can distort the decision
And here comes the interesting question: if this is legally fragile, how did it become so culturally powerful?
The Internet Cycle: When Celebrities Become "Messages from Beyond"
Now we enter the territory where the topic becomes an engagement wildfire.
In recent years, content presented as "psychographed letters" attributed to famous people has reappeared in waves. A case that resurfaced in 2025 was that of Allana Moraes, girlfriend of singer Cristiano Araújo (who died in 2015). Articles and posts cite an "alleged psychographed letter attributed to Allana" and highlight repercussion among fans.
Another recent cycle involves letters attributed to MC Kevin, with posts from family members and wide circulation in columns and portals.
Here, two things happen simultaneously:
- The content serves as a "public ritual" of longing
- The digital environment creates a market where every ritual can be monetized
And it's in this crack that the most dangerous problem enters: grief exploitation.
The Part Almost No One Wants to Face: Grief Fraud
In January 2026, a new wave of attention emerged with reports about websites selling psychographed letters offering "packages" and "delivery deadlines." This topic circulated in social media posts and in articles mentioning prices, upsells, and complaints.
Even when the subject appears in different sources, the pattern is similar:
- You choose the "medium" from a catalog
- Choose "deadline" and "type" of letter
- Pay
- And receive (or don't receive) something that may be generic
Why is this so serious? Because grief is vulnerability. And vulnerability is fraud's preferred target.
An important sign: within more established Spiritist traditions, there's strong disapproval of "charging for mediumship." The debate appears in public reactions to the topic.
Checklist: 12 Warning Signs of Scams
If you want to protect yourself or warn someone, this list is essential:
⚠️ Warning Signs:
- Guarantee promises ("you'll definitely receive it")
- Delivery deadline (grief isn't delivery)
- Packages and add-ons ("extra audio," "premium letter," "urgency fee")
- Request for too much intimate data (photos, detailed stories — this allows "custom" text)
- Generic text (universal phrases that work for any family)
- Emotional pressure ("if you love them, do it")
- Too-perfect testimonials (seem scripted)
- Payment through obscure intermediaries
- Channels that reappear every week with "new bombshell letters"
- Mix of accusation + letter (attempt to "solve case" with emotion)
- Use to attack someone (letter becomes weapon)
- Total lack of transparency (who is the person, how they work, what community)
This doesn't "prove" everything is fraud. But it greatly reduces your chance of falling into a trap.
"But What If It's True?" — The Most Delicate Point
This is where most texts fail: they either mock believers or affirm as if it were science.
The stronger path is different:
- Recognize that there are people who report real comfort
- And, at the same time, separate comfort from proof
A critical analysis of psychography in court explains why this type of content doesn't hold up as evidence and how the hypothesis isn't testable in a way that serves the legal model of evidence.
This gives you a "mature investigation" tone:
"It's not about attacking faith. It's about preventing emotion from becoming a manipulation tool."
Why This Topic Competes for Voter Attention
In election season, the real battle isn't just proposals — it's attention. And attention is driven by:
- Fear
- Outrage
- Shock
- Emotion
Psychographed letters "in famous cases" are perfect for this engine, because:
- They generate immediate moral debate ("respect the pain" vs "this is a scam")
- They create conflict and comments
- They put "justice" at the center of the subject (especially after the STJ ruling)
In other words: this topic becomes a mirror of Brazil. A country where faith is strong, grief is collective, and digital sometimes transforms pain into product.
Cases with Greatest Repercussion
Group A — Court and Social Rupture
- Kiss Nightclub (trial and letter controversy)
- STJ Ruling (2025) prohibiting as evidence
Group B — Celebrities and Viral Waves
- Cristiano Araújo / Allana Moraes (alleged letter)
- MC Kevin (shared letter and repercussion)
Group C — Reports and Grief Exploitation
- Sale of letters and suspicions/complaints (Jan/2026)
Conclusion: The Question That Separates Awareness from Manipulation
If there's a simple rule for navigating this topic, it's this:
If the message asks you to stop thinking and just feel, turn on the alert.
Because comfort doesn't need urgency, doesn't need a package, doesn't need an upsell, and doesn't need to become a weapon in court or on the internet.
And, after what the STJ established, the public lesson becomes even clearer: faith is intimate — but proof and public truth require criteria.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can psychographed letters be used as judicial evidence?
No. The STJ ruled in 2025 that they cannot be admitted as evidence and ordered their removal from the case.
Why did the Kiss Nightclub case become a landmark?
Because an alleged letter was presented at the trial, generating strong repercussion and debate about emotional influence in judicial decisions.
How to identify scams involving psychographed letters?
Be suspicious of promises, delivery deadlines, "packages," extra charges, and emotional pressure. Use the 12-sign checklist in this article.
Are there famous cases that went viral?
Yes, there are recurring waves with letters attributed to celebrities like Cristiano Araújo/Allana Moraes and MC Kevin.
Does Spiritism charge for psychography?
More established Spiritist traditions disapprove of charging for mediumship. Sites that sell "letters with deadlines" don't represent these traditions.
